“Is it more unethical to allow threats to students/schools or to deny students/teachers access to instructionally-relevant Web-based tools and content?”
Imagine a garden paradise where everywhere you look you find rich, luscious fruit trees (persimmon, pear, apple, etc.), ripe and exploding with flavor. You are told from any tree you may feast but not to taste from the tree at the center of the garden. For if you do all of your innocence will be lost.
Sound familiar? How do you think this story would have turned out if God would have put up a firewall and blocked access to the tree? Would we still be in that garden paradise? Was the fruit made with the purpose to be tasted and inevitably eaten so that we could become aware?
Is it more unethical to allow threats to students, or to deny students access to instructionally relevant content? Do we push technological advancement into the classroom allowing students to have access to digital media like cell phones and laptops? What if this technology causes disruption? What if students use it to cheat?
If the students are on school provided technology restrictions should be made to restrict access to content that may endanger the system (such as viruses worms). Network ids and passwords for individuals to log-in giving them deferent security privileges is a great way to accomplish this. With cell phones evolving into smart phones to someday growing into just a hand computer that’s awesome and does everything the students will be constantly wired in and free from any blocking. There would be no denying them instructionally relevant material. Content on their devises would only be limited if they were underage and the students parents wanted to password protect and block certain sites based on moral beliefs. So on their own we can encourage them to grow with out any restrictions.
Ethics should be taught and encouraged on all of these new technologies just the same way we would in teach and encourage students to communicate amongst each other in a group. Not to cheat, not to disrupt, to be good, and respectful of their peers. Technology is the new guy. Accept him.
The bad behaviors of students have always been there.
At my school every student has a brand new Mac laptop and usually on their own they own an iphone, Android, Blackberry, whatever… This is a daily part of my teaching experience and it is exciting that the students have these tools available to complement with their learning. We have to evolve and learn to deal with technologies cause they are coming if they are not already here. Accepting this might make this fruit a bit easier to swallow.
Resources:
Gunter, G. A., Gunter, R. E., & Shelly, G.B. (2010). Integrating Technology and Digital Media in the Classroom (6th ed.). United States: Course Technology, Cengage Learning.
http://cpsr.org/issues/ethics/cei/
http://www.mythencyclopedia.com/A-Am/Adam-and-Eve.html
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Persimmon